I was astonished that mainstream media had finally picked up on a concept that I had learned about the hard way: vigorous exercise does not aid in weight loss, eating healthy and unfortunately less food is the key.
Now for all of you exercise haters out there, this is not permission to lay on the couch all day. What it means is that running 5 miles every day or going to the gym and killing yourself for an hour every day does not automatically mean the pounds will come off.
One of three problems usually arises when you do strenuous exercise:
- If you are restricting calories your energy begins to dwindle and you feel awful.
- Exercise makes you hungry (usually for sweet foods) which can lead to binge eating.
- You’ve exercised therefore you can eat whatever you want or reward eating.
Pick up any marathon training book and it will tell you that it's not a great idea to try and lose weight and train for a marathon at the same time. These experts know that running 30+ miles a week and restricting calories won't work.
I hated to restrict my eating so for years I exercised, sometimes twice a day, just so I could know that I had the freedom to eat what I wanted. I wasn't a bad eater. In fact, being a vegetarian and health nut, I was very conscious of what I ate. My problem was that I indulged when I wanted to by eating sweets and my portions, though healthy, were just too big.
I once had someone ask me how much I exercised in a week and when I told them they asked me why I wasn't stick thin? I was dumbfounded. Why the hell wasn't I stick thin!!
I had to admit defeat. I needed to reduce the amount of food I was eating, even if most of it was considered healthy.
Running three times a week 3-5 miles and yoga were just enough for me. I was eating around 1500 calories, I had tons of energy and the extra weight was falling off. I even had one day where I could indulge in whatever I wanted and still I lost weight.
Then I started training for my second marathon and once I started running over 25 miles per week, goodbye carrots hello vegan brownies (they may be vegan but they still have calories).
Luckily for me I saw it coming. It's been challenging but I have adjusted my diet to keep myself fueledand have put the remaining weight loss to the side until after the event. Even now it’s hard to swear off that pint of soy ice cream after a 16 mile run. I don't always succeed but I do try to be more conscious of what is happening.
So what does that mean for those of us trying to live healthy? I wish there was another way but sadly if you want to get to a healthy weight (healthy not skinny!) less food is key. However, we still need to move. Exercise might not be the solution to weight loss but it is beneficial to us in many other ways.
You need to find your balance. Pay attention to what and how much you are eating. Instead of running those five miles every day and having that muffin or cupcake afterward, reduce running to every other day and skip the sweets.
Try more moderate and mindful exercise like yoga or walking. Take the stairs, walk or bike instead of driving and cook more often (just say no to take-out!). If you like to do the occasional race, go for it but just be aware of the changes your body goes through when exercise is increased.
You want the changes you make to your eating and fitness to be for life. Do what you can maintain and remember that moderation lasts.